Análisis de mercadovintagemodernscarlet-violet

Vintage vs Modern Pokémon Cards: Which Holds Value in 2026?

Vintage vs modern Pokémon cards: over 12 months, 2003-2011 cards are up 127% and Scarlet & Violet 10%, but −25% since June. What falls, what rises.

20 min read

By Yohan ArroyaveHobby Pokémon TCG collector

Seven weeks ago I wrote that the Pokémon market wasn't crashing but correcting, at two speeds: modern going down and vintage hitting records. I went back to the data to see whether that held up and to answer the bigger question (vintage vs modern Pokémon cards: which one is worth more today), this time with something I didn't have back then: a full year of daily and weekly prices for thousands of cards, split by era. The short answer is that modern isn't dead: its bubble is over. Vintage is climbing hard, and the modern chase cards are paying the bill.

Before going on, the usual disclaimer: I'm not an appraiser or an analyst. I started collecting this year, as a hobby, and the numbers come from our own TCGPlayer price database (Near Mint, English cards, in US dollars), checked against eBay. It's a snapshot of a market, with its limits, and further down I tell you what they are.

In short

  • Vintage rose all year. Cards from the EX, DP and HGSS era (2003-2011) are up +20.3% in three months and +127% in twelve; Wizards cards, +9.6% and +76%.
  • Scarlet & Violet is correcting, not collapsing. −19.8% in three months (82% of its cards are down), but still +10% versus a year ago. The peak was in June, and since then it has lost 25%.
  • The SIRs are paying for it. −24% in three months and −8% over the year: the only large Scarlet & Violet rarity class in the red over twelve months. Regular ex cards, on the other hand, barely moved: −2%.
  • Sealed holds up. Typical Scarlet & Violet sealed product is down only 1% in three months.
  • The fine print: the typical vintage card sells 14 to 23 times in three months; the typical Scarlet & Violet card, 176. The vintage rise is measured on far fewer sales.

One year in one chart: vintage against modern

To avoid cherry-picking single cards, I built three fixed baskets: the same cards from start to finish, added up as if you had a binder with one copy of each. They all start at 100 on November 10, 2025.

Vintage vs modern over 12 months: price index (Nov 10, 2025 = 100)
100150200250Nov 25FebMayAugNov 26EX/DP/HGSS227WOTC176SV110peak: 147 (Jun 29)
  • EX, DP and HGSS (2003-2011), 76 cards
  • WOTC (1999-2003), 272 cards
  • Scarlet & Violet (2023-2025), 548 cards

TCGPlayer market price (Near Mint, English, USD), every Monday, from November 10, 2025 to November 16, 2026. Each line is a fixed basket: the same cards all year, weighted by value (like a binder with one copy of each).

The Wizards line (1999-2003) didn't have a single down week all year. The EX, DP and HGSS line had only one, in mid-December, and hasn't stopped since. The Scarlet & Violet line did something else: it fell until January, rose faster than anything else until June 29, and since then it has been giving ground back week after week.

The dividing line is 2020. Everything before Sword & Shield is up over the last three months and everything after is down, almost in order of age:

EX, DP and HGSS

+20.3%

3 months · 423 cards · 76% are up

Wizards

+9.6%

3 months · 783 cards

Scarlet & Violet

−19.8%

3 months · 904 cards · 82% are down

Era (3 months, mid-August to mid-November)ChangeCards
Wizards (1999-2003)+9.6%783
EX, DP and HGSS (2003-2011)+20.3%423
Black & White and XY (2011-2016)+12.2%667
Sun & Moon (2017-2019)+5.3%864
Sword & Shield (2020-2023)−9.3%687
Scarlet & Violet (2023-2025)−19.8%904

The three-month figures come from a wider sample than the chart, which is why they don't match its lines to the decimal.

Is modern Pokémon crashing? No, it's correcting

Here I have to be honest about what I wrote in October, because part of it didn't hold up.

Didn't hold up

"Modern chase cards have already stabilized"

I wrote that on October 4, looking at one flat week. I was wrong: from October 5 to November 16 the Scarlet & Violet index lost another 12%, and the Umbreon ex SIR that was at $1,326.66 back then is worth $1,147.59 today. A flat week wasn't a floor.

Held up

"Vintage is at record highs"

And it still is: since October 5, EX, DP and HGSS cards are up another 9% and Wizards cards 4%.

Held up

"Brand-new releases are still falling"

The two newest sets in the sample, Chaos Rising and Pitch Black, fell 44% in three months. I left them out of the "modern" figures, along with the first Mega Evolution sets, because there the normal drop of a new set gets mixed up with the general correction.

But it isn't the end of modern either, and the chart shows it. Scarlet & Violet is coming off its best first half in a long time: the basket went from 88 to 147 between January and June. Today it's at 110. It hurts, yes, but it's still above a year ago, and the typical card in that basket is worth 27% more than in November 2025. What ended is the bubble of the first half of 2026, not the value of modern cards.

It isn't just the usual drop of freshly released sets, either. The 2025 sets fall the most (−21.9% in three months), but the 2023 sets aren't spared (−17.9%): 151 is down 25% and Obsidian Flames 23%. The ones having the worst time are Journey Together (−31%) and Destined Rivals (−38%).

The ones paying the bill: modern chase cards

Within Scarlet & Violet, not everything falls the same. Chase cards fall twice as much as the rest:

Scarlet & Violet by rarity3 months
Special Illustration Rare (SIR)−24.4%
Illustration Rare (IR)−22.2%
Full art (ultra rare)−14.2%
Hyper and gold−10.2%
Regular ex (double rare)−2.2%

Over twelve months the picture changes: SIRs lose 7.9% and are the only large Scarlet & Violet class in the red for the full year. IRs, which have fallen almost as much since August, are still up 38.0% because they had climbed a lot before.

These three SIRs are the hardest cases in the sample, not the typical card (the median SIR is down 23%). But all three are worth less today than a year ago:

View on TCGPlayer
View on TCGPlayer
View on TCGPlayer

Prices updated on November 22, 2026 · TCGPlayer via TCGdex

How to read the cards. "Nov 2025" is the TCGPlayer price in mid-November 2025; "Aug 2026", the average from August 18 to 20; "At publish", the close on November 19, 2026. The percentages in the text compare three-day averages, so they may differ slightly from the math on the cards. "Now" updates live.

Team Rocket's Mewtwo ex went from $495 in August to $279, and Cynthia's Garchomp ex from $243 to $147. These aren't one-day drops: they fell week after week, with hundreds of sales on TCGPlayer, and eBay follows them (the Mewtwo, from about $524 to $300 in the eBay median).

Two other chase cards add nuance. Prismatic Evolutions' Umbreon ex fell 21% since August, but it's worth almost the same as a year ago: it was a round trip. And the Brilliant Stars Charizard V alt art (Sword & Shield, not Scarlet & Violet) falls more slowly but steadily: −22% in three months and −26% in twelve.

View on TCGPlayer
View on TCGPlayer

Prices updated on November 22, 2026 · TCGPlayer via TCGdex

What about sealed? It holds up much better than single cards. In three months, typical Scarlet & Violet sealed product is down 1%, against 17% for the typical card. Among booster boxes, the 2025 ones fall the most; the 2023 and 2024 ones are almost flat:

Destined Rivals Booster Box

$376

May $639 · August $435 · −14% in 3 months

Journey Together Booster Box

$199

August $300 · −34% in 3 months

Paldea Evolved Booster Box

$465

August $463 · +0.4%

Surging Sparks Booster Box

$300

August $303 · −1%

Obsidian Flames Booster Box

$381

August $367 · +4%

TCGPlayer prices, three-day average in the middle of each month. If sealed barely moves and SIRs do, what's deflating is the premium on the most sought-after single card, not interest in the product.

The ones going up: vintage with real sales

On the vintage side I picked three cards whose rise also shows up on eBay, not just in the TCGPlayer price. None of them jumped overnight: they climbed in steps, week after week.

View on TCGPlayer
View on TCGPlayer
View on TCGPlayer

Prices updated on November 22, 2026 · TCGPlayer via TCGdex

  • Gengar GL (Rising Rivals, 2009): from $26 in August to $38, and from about $8 a year ago. On eBay, from $15 to $33.
  • Dark Celebi (Hidden Legends, 2004): from $74 to $86 in three months, and from $33 a year ago. On eBay it went from about $54 to about $100.
  • Mew, Wizards promo #47: from $149 to $163, and from $87 a year ago. eBay is up too (from about $130 to about $235), although with few sales.

Notice the scale: these are cards worth tens or a few hundred dollars, not grails. This year's vintage rise isn't only about record-breaking cards.

Take with a grain of salt

The Base Set 2 Mewtwo: +147% on TCGPlayer, but eBay doesn't confirm it

It's the most eye-catching rise in the sample: from $67 in August to $165. But it rests on one to five sales a week, and on eBay it isn't clear (about $50 in August, $34 in October with two sales, between $66 and $90 in November with one or two). It may be real, or it may be a price that moves on very few transactions. I wouldn't draw conclusions from it.

View on TCGPlayer

Prices updated on November 22, 2026 · TCGPlayer via TCGdex

Why modern Pokémon cards fall and vintage ones rise

I separate what's documented from what's opinion, because a lot of numbers with no source float around on this topic.

What's a fact:

  • Modern print runs are huge. The Pokémon Company printed about 10 billion cards in its 2025-26 fiscal year, and the all-time total is over 85 billion. In 2021 it was 34.1 billion: in five years more was printed than in the previous 25 (Kotaku, May 27, 2026). The single-year record was 11.9 billion, in 2023-24 (SNKRDUNK, with data from The Pokémon Company).
  • The company said it would print at full capacity. In March 2025 it wrote that it was working to reprint sold-out products "as quickly as possible and at maximum capacity" (pokemon.com, March 27, 2025).
  • The money hasn't left the hobby. According to Card Ladder, over $1.07 billion in cards (sports included) sold in October 2026, the first month in history above one billion (Sports Illustrated, November 2, 2026). And PSA graded 2.5 million cards in June 2026, a record, with TCG cards above 71% (Sports Illustrated with GemRate data).
  • The EX era is having its strongest fall. With Collectr data, 12 Delta Species cards rose 177% on average between August 4 and November 4, 2026 (TheGamer, November 4, 2026). That lines up with the release of Delta Reign on November 6, the modern set that pays tribute to Delta Species, but no source I read says one causes the other.

What's opinion or interpretation:

  • TheGamer attributes the Delta Species rise to "the scalping and investing that is ruining the hobby" and to there being very few PSA 10 copies, because almost nobody graded when they came out. In other words: part of the vintage rise is speculation too.
  • Ken Goldin (Goldin Auctions, whose business is this market) said on CNBC in December 2025 that today there are "less people that are looking to get in to make a quick buck" than in 2020-2021 (ICv2).
  • My read, which is only that: at 10 billion cards a year, the most sought-after modern card stops being scarce as soon as the set gets reprinted and opened en masse. The old card can't be reprinted, and if on top of that almost nobody graded it, perfect copies are few. That explains the direction. The speed, not so much.

It has happened once before. In 2021-2022 the company printed about 9 billion cards in one year, more than double the year before, and modern cooled off (Fortune, July 6, 2022). What I couldn't find is a reliable source on how much vintage fell in that cycle, so I won't claim it held up.

What this data doesn't tell you

This is the part that took me the most work, and the one that matters most so I don't mislead you.

Vintage sells much less

The typical EX, DP and HGSS card sold 14 times on TCGPlayer in three months; the typical Wizards card, 23; the typical Scarlet & Violet card, 176. The modern drop is measured with hundreds of sales per card, the vintage rise with dozens. If I keep only vintage cards with 30 or more sales, the typical card barely moves over three months: +0.7% for Wizards and +1.7% for EX, DP and HGSS. Over six months it does rise clearly (+10% and +27%), so the trend is real, but its short-term size is fragile.

Many vintage cards are missing

About 780 vintage series that are worth $20 or more today (328 from Wizards and 454 from EX, DP and HGSS) had no price in mid-August, so they don't count. In Scarlet & Violet only 2 are missing. The vintage rise is measured on the minority of cards that do sell, and that bias can go either way.

Only ungraded cards, in English

Everything is raw Near Mint in English. No graded cards, no Japanese, no other languages. And the TCGPlayer market price carries the last value forward on days without sales: on a card that sells once a week, a "rise" can just be the price catching up.

With all that, the direction holds in both sources: on eBay, the typical Wizards card is up 12% in three months and the typical Scarlet & Violet card is down 11%. What I wouldn't claim is that vintage will keep rising at the same pace.

So, vintage or modern?

I don't have an investment answer, and I'd be wary of anyone who gives you one with confidence. What I do see in the data, with collectors in mind:

  • If you love a modern set, now is a better time than the summer. Scarlet & Violet SIRs are 24% cheaper than in August, and several are below where they were a year ago.
  • Modern didn't turn into junk. Regular ex cards barely moved, 2023-2024 sealed is flat and the Scarlet & Violet basket is still above November 2025. What fell was the chase-card premium.
  • Vintage has been the most consistent, but it sells little. If you buy vintage, check how many sales a card has before trusting its chart.
  • Be wary of a single card's rise. The Base Set 2 Mewtwo is the example: +147% that eBay doesn't confirm.

If you want the October context, it's in the analysis of whether the market was correcting. The auction records that hold up the top end of vintage are in the all-time records list, and the era of Delta Species and Gold Stars is in part three of the TCG history. For the extreme case of a modern set deflating in weeks, see 30th Celebration against its launch, and if you're wondering how much PSA 10 weighs in all this, there's the 2026 grading guide. This month's card-by-card detail is in November's biggest gainers and losers.

Free tools

Is your collection more vintage or more modern?

In the Collection Tracker you mark what you own and see its value live, card by card, with what went up and down over the week and the month. It works just as well for a Wizards binder as for a Scarlet & Violet master set.

About the prices

  • Cards and sealed: TCGPlayer market price (Near Mint, English, USD) from our daily series via PokéTrace, with weekly snapshots (every Monday) before February 2026. Data cutoff: November 19, 2026. The eBay medians come from the same source.
  • How each era is calculated: each (card, finish) pair is a series; a series is included if it was worth $5 or more at the start, has at least 6 sales in the period and shows no odd jumps on the comparison dates. Changes are value-weighted (a binder with one copy of each card). Three months: average of August 18 to 20 against November 17 to 19, 2026. Twelve months: fixed basket from November 10, 2025. Sets released in the 90 days before each start date are excluded.
  • What updates live: the "Now" row on each card. Everything else (cards, chart, tables and tiles) is a dated snapshot that doesn't change.
  • External sources: the ones linked in the section on why modern cards fall and vintage ones rise. Third-party figures are cited with their outlet and date.

TCGPlayer prices (USD) as a global reference; your local market may vary. Editorial reference, not investment advice.

Found this useful? Share it

Prices, movers and cards that spike or crash, every week on Instagram and TikTok.

Subscribe to the RSS feed

Get every new article in your favorite reader

View feed ↗